
📚 Author Interview:
A bowling alley is a strange place to die. For Mac, it’s also the last familiar thing he sees before waking up in Holoch, where an eldritch god has turned survival into a game. In this BookCypher interview, we talk with Alistair MacAoigh about Cold Steel Mac: Defy the Gods, a fantasy LitRPG about a world-weary man who has little interest in glory and even less patience for the god who expects him to play along.
📖 About the Book
For readers discovering Cold Steel Mac: Defy the Gods for the first time, what is the story about, and what can they expect from it?
Cold Steel Mac is a story that sets up the classic fantasy LitRpg tropes; a man sent to another world, a quest from a god, and magical powers. It then turns them on their head. The man doesn’t want glory. The god isn’t as in control as one would expect from a deity. The powers are available to his enemies as well as our hero. It features Mac, who is an older man who carries a whole history with him and is antagonistic to authority, and Gracie, a hard swinging young woman who still wants to save the world – even if she has to drag this old man halfway across the planet to do it.
What inspired the original idea for this novel?
I was in a discussion around certain fantasy tropes and the topic of backstories came up. A lot of fantasy characters and RPG characters share some very common tropes – The hero’s family doesn’t exist, they don’t questions the ridiculous quests they are sent on, and they are always interested in being either really good or really edgy. A comment stuck with me however. Someone asked, “Can you imaging if the glorious champion of light was divorced? And his ex-wife wasn’t an evil witch?”
That stuck with me. I’ve done older and cynical characters before, but the idea of a hero that was human – that had made mistakes and had to live with them long before they picked up the sword and started their hero’s journey. I started to plan Mac first – a man who shared blame for his failed marriage and haphazard parenting, but was old enough to realize it. Someone who would undertake the quest with a full understanding of what it can cost to really put yourself on the line.
I then created the system that he would live in and realized that I wanted the system itself to have a personality. LitRpg and Isekai characters conflict with their systems all the time, but outside Dungeon Crawler Carl it normally a one sided relationship. I drew up ideas for Holoch and things kind of fell into place from there. A old man that was so angry that he would be handed a chance to save the world but whose first response to meeting god would be to throw god the middle finger.
How did the character of Mac first come to life in your imagination?
I started with the basic ideas of Mac I had come up with but then needed some key moments in his past that would help inform how he would react to the events of the story. The first was his divorce. I knew he couldn’t just be a terrible person that people would feel bad rooting for, but I didn’t want Carol (his ex-wife) to be a terrible person either. Most divorces aren’t actually between an utter saint and a devil. Instead its two broken people who lost something they had along the way. So Carol became overwhelmed by being in a family and handled it badly, but Mac also handled things badly. He gets grumpy and outright antagonistic when things go wrong. I also then added a son – Dresmond. A good kid that both parents could agree on had worked out despite themselves.
The second event is alluded to in the book and is a bit of a spoiler, but Mac has killed someone before, on Earth. He didn’t suffer the expected legal consequences, but it destroyed his idea of being a noble person. No matter what happens to him, he’s still the man who once let a fight get out of control. It leads to him distrusting anyone claiming to be infallible.
The final event is the start of the book. I threw him right in front of Holoch, an elder god with very traditional expectations of mortals and let the sparks fly. In that moment, Mac came together. A man too old to back down, but too angry to die. Someone who wouldn’t seek to be a hero, but couldn’t run away from his responsibilities either.
The concept of waking up in a game-like world has become popular with readers. What unique elements did you want to bring to the genre?
This is the first pure LitRpg I’ve written, but several of my previous works used universes that had been written on video game principles. I’ve written a lot of computer code in my life, so the idea of such systems is natural to me. I wanted to build a simple system that was also somewhat unpredictable. A lot of LitRpg systems, even the really good ones, often start with very strict interactions and then the author has to later break up or layer additional systems on to add some of the magical mystery back. I instead wanted to build that mystery in from the ground up, so I decided to rely on the idea of combining elements. With two elements and a unique object put together, the number of combinations is an awful lot and I think that gives a lot of power.
You can see it with Mac. While his companions focus on getting one really powerful weapon, he starts to build an arsenal. His knives aren’t as deadly as Gracie’s mace or Rufus’s crossbow, but he has a knife for every situation.
I also wanted to have a system that wasn’t fully in control. The great thing about having an Eldritch God in control is that Holoch seems omnipotent at first. That makes sense to a western audience who is used to monotheist deities – why wouldn’t god know everything and be in charge of everything? As the story develops Mac comes to realize that he’s made the same assumptions. In reality, Holoch has more in common with Zeus than Jesus Christ. As Holoch tries to keep control, his system risks unraveling around the both of them.
Why did you choose the title Cold Steel Mac: Defy the Gods?
(Laughs). This is the first book in a long time where I’ve ever been really stumped on the title. I blame myself. I had a hero called Mac and gave him knives, but you can’t really call a book Mac the Knife without confusing jazz fans. I was brainstorming a lot of ideas around Mac and his signature weapon when Cold Steel Mac came up. The title was funny to me. Cold Steel is a famous weapon company, but with Mac’s name at the end it sounds like a dish served up at the Restaurant at the End of the Universe. I kept trying for something more serious, but by the time the book was finished I realized it fit. Cold Steel Mac is a book that is about not taking expectations or authority serious and the title fits that. Defy the Gods is both the mission statement of the first book and a hint to the reader on how central defying any and all authority is to the theme of the book.
⚔️ Worldbuilding & Adventure
Holoch is a fascinating and dangerous world. How did you go about creating it? – (Author Note: The planet is called Holoch’s World. I know its a little weird)
Once I built the system and Holoch I worked on some of the basics, but tried not to get too deep into details until the reader got into it. A lot fo the world is blatantly built so Mac can walk to where he needs to go, but as we started building it was surprising how important Holoch became. The world is filled with millions of human beings, all of whom know about Holoch but have very different reactions to living within his system and to having a god that frankly, sets the up to be a sideshow to his own entertainment. If your god is a dangerous Eldritch being that demands entertainment, do you avoid his gaze or seek to control it? A lot of the religions and governments on Holoch’s World are built as answers to that question.
What was the most enjoyable aspect of designing the world, creatures, and systems within the story?
The idea that you could meet mortals and immortals could interact with each other and not understand each other became fascinating. Holoch is a clearly available god you can talk to and get easily understood benefits from, but I realized that didn’t mean his cult would agree on how to enact his will or wether he deserved worship.
Next I tried to give myself the freedom to avoid some of the traditional fantasy tropes where they wouldn’t help. The rule was that if the creature didn’t need to be a classic Orc or Troll, than it wouldn’t be. That led to a lot of fun things like the Diana and the bone-creatures from the ash forest.
Letting the characters make non-optimal choices was important too. Mac doesn’t always get just the right tool for the job and he doesn’t always make the best choices when leveling. This keeps up the mystery as to what he’ll do next and what kind of character he will be by the end.
How do the game mechanics, quests, and leveling systems shape the story without overshadowing the characters?
The part of the system that works the best came about as an accident in Cold Steel Mac. When I had designed the system, its magic, and its classes, I really had not considered spreading it to monsters and their types like is traditionally done. That could have been a problem with the characters becoming overpowered compared to their opponents, but instead it let me give the monsters a lot of options that might not otherwise fit within the system.
Ironically, the opposite proved true as well. When the opponents were fellow ‘players’ in Holoch’s system, they could exploit it just as much as the protagonists could. Its one thing when the hero builds a ‘peasant railgun’, but when the enemy does it that can be quite surprising!
Were there any locations, cultures, myths, or historical influences that helped inspire parts of Holoch?
The ‘True Church’ of Holoch, one of the bigger groups of those trying to obey his will, was very much inspired by historical groups that have often started with a sense of their own superiority and then stumbled into fascism. They started as a traditional cult dedicated to worshiping an Eldritch god for power, but you can see the members of the cult slowly start to hear realize that their quest for personal power has started to cross some serious boundaries.
Likewise, when it came to the larger battles between armies, I pulled a lot of inspiration from WWI and WWII as both war’s European theater involved a lot of fighting in short distances between major cities of differing nations. Mac rarely interacts with these directly, but if you think of the Free Cities as French a lot of stuff starts to become familiar quickly.
If readers could explore one place from the book in real life, which location would you most want them to experience?
I think a lot of people would want to visit the Clockwork city. The idea of an underground city that sprang up so quickly there was no time to organize anything, but to spread out in all three dimensions, is really interesting. That’s not counting the active volcano the whole thing is parked next to.
I personally would want to visit the Market of Seaspire. Seeing all those cloth-covered buildings, the colorful scarves, and the constant chatter as people gossip and cheer on their favorite heroes would be fantastic to see.
🧙 Characters & Relationships
What makes Mac an interesting protagonist to write?
I think the most interesting part of Mac is not just his antagonistic nature, but the fact that he is also aware of it. He explodes easily, but he also has the experience to know that you can’t just do that an pretend to be the superior person afterward. He is also not great with people. For someone who is so confident in telling the local god to stuff himself, he is also incredible uncertain about how to deal with the people around him. When the answer does not involve a blade or a flippant attitude, you can see a less stable, more uncertain version of Mac and I enjoyed writing that.
Which character surprised you the most during the writing process?
I hadn’t really intended Suti to be a permanent character. I had the two buddies for my buddy cop dynamic, so what use would I have for a third? As I wrote however, I realized that she bridged a key missing part of the dynamic between Mac and Gracie. Mac isn’t very emphatic because of his stubbornness and Gracie isn’t because of her certainty in her youth. Suti however, can provide that empathetic ear that gets them talking and thinking even after they argue. The fact that she is a native that then has to handle these two crazy Earth people creates a lot of fun dynamics as well
Do you share any personality traits or experiences with Mac?
I am a naturally defiant person like Mac, and I’m an older person who realizes that is a problem like him to. I hadn’t meant to associate so closely with this character but as someone who had to struggle with a Neurodivergence during the era in which authority was both trying to be confident in their solutions and yet were clearly learning as they went. Like Mac, I know what its like to have to rely on a system that is trying to help but is also using you as an experimental trial run. Mac handles things more reasonably than the teenage version of me did, admittedly.
Which relationship or friendship in the book was the most rewarding to develop?
Having Carol and Mac meet up was very rewarding. Having Carol being a breakout success was originally part of the humor. Of course Mac’s ex-wife is here. Of course she’s famous and popular. I hadn’t realized how that would reflect on their divorce though. Carol crashed because she couldn’t handle being a family woman, and her success makes it hard for Mac to argue against that. The fact that they have so much conflict in their history but have learned to put that aside every time for Dresmond also lead to a kind of sweet moment.
Was there a particular character you found especially challenging to write? Why?
Musa, who is a dark and brooding yet extremely personable spy, was hard. I didn’t want him to join the stubborn finger-flipping party that Gracie and Mac often indulged in, but I didn’t want him to just be the opposite of them either. In the end, having him act as a kind of mirror to Suti worked. Musa is a professional who believes in the system, without all the reservations Suti has about people in power. He smiles, but its not necessarily a genuine one – he’s been taught how to present himself as needed and that makes him a kind of unreliable narrator in his own right.
✍️ The Writing Process
What does your typical writing routine look like?
My goal every day is to write 1750 words – if I can. I often join writing competitions like Nanowrimo (when it was around) to keep myself on track. My goal is to write a complete scene and when I reach my goal, to maybe fix some spelling or minor grammar issues. Once the first draft is finished I give the whole thing a read. Depending on the results, I will either go over the draft sentence by sentence, or I will rewrite the entire thing with the first draft as a guide. Its a lot of work, but it forces me to rewrite a lot of awkward sentences.
Are you a detailed planner, a discovery writer, or somewhere in between?
Normally I do a lot of planning – pages of design documents and a whole outline. For this novel however, I decided to do a try Pantser experience, staring with just a couple pages of notes and no major outline. It led me to a lot of unexpected places in the plot when I was free to just create a plot twist and follow it to its natural conclusion
What were the biggest challenges you encountered while writing this book?
I am going to get in some trouble for this, but the numbers. I thought of myself as naturally a numbers kind of guy, but tracking experience points, power levels, and inventory was a lot more work than I had anticipated. The fact that Mac has such a large array of knives made looting especially interesting, since I often had to go over the list and remember what all this stuff was supposed to do.
How long did it take from the initial idea to the finished manuscript?
It took ninety days as part of a writer’s event. Normally I wouldn’t expect to finish the editing so quickly, but things really worked out for Cold Steel Mac
What part of the writing journey are readers often surprised to learn about?
How little of it was preplanned. A lot of writing is letting your characters do crazy things and then to see where the consequences land. I didn’t know where Mac would finish the story, but I let the antagonists do what they wanted to win, and he came barreling into their plans like a wrecking ball. I won’t spoil it, but the final big enemy of the novel wasn’t someone I had planned at all until I got to the end and realized that this was where the plot was going.
🎮 Themes, Influences & Genre
Beyond the action and adventure, what deeper themes did you hope readers would take away from the story?
Defy Authority. In a more serious manner, I think one of the biggest questions that people are asking that fantasy isn’t answering is what do you do when your Hogwarts letter doesn’t arrive? If you aren’t young and fit and immortal anymore can you still be a hero? I hope that Mac answers that question for some people.
Were there any authors, books, games, films, or other influences that helped shape this novel?
I’ll forever be thankfully to Jim Butcher for demonstrating how a flippant character can work while still having depth. If you are a writer, its worth it to read some of the articles and interviews he’s done over the years. Classic console RPGs was also a big influence. My father was a manager in a video game mall kiosk for a while and I borrowed a lot of talks and stories I collected from the mall rats that used to occupy his store.
The idea of fate versus free will plays a role in many epic adventures. How does that theme appear in Mac’s journey?
Mac is in the position that is normally occupied by a chosen savior and Holoch has a whole plot arc set out for him and the other sixty seven people from Earth. All of that was set up and Mac crashing into it with his natural defiance and stubbornness is, in a lot of ways, the key driving mechanism of the plot.
What do you think makes progression fantasy and LitRPG stories so appealing to modern readers?
Before Dakota Krout and other LitRpg authors hit the scene fantasy has lost much of its wonder. Authors were often writing books in familiar tropes and magic systems, which meant that a lot of interaction was predictable. People make a big deal out of ‘watching numbers go up’, but I don’t think that is really the draw of LitRpgs so much as that feeling when you get a new video game or rpg and you’ve never played in it before. You read about all these systems and there is an element of wonder as you try to figure out how all these pieces fit and what they can do for you. A good LitRpg should do the same thing. Show all the pieces and let the reader wonder not only how you’ll use those bits but what they might do with them if given a chance. We all know how Mac uses the system, but I bet a lot of readers know they could do better if given the chance.
🌟 Behind the Author
What first inspired you to become a writer?
My mother was a bookseller, so we did a lot of reading in my family. I became fascinated when I encountered a lot of my father’s old science fiction and fantasy novels. Each author had a different voice, a different set of principles and very different ideals. I spent a lot of time wondering about what I might do it put into the Foundation or in the world of the Darksword trilogy. The idea that so many heroes journeys could come to so many conclusions has really stuck with me over the years.
When did you realize writing was something you wanted to pursue seriously?
I was writing yet another design document for a video game when I asked myself a serious question. If this world is believable, could I write short stories within it? I started and found I really enjoyed it. It was like playing a video game on paper. Setting up a system and a world, and then letting some crazy character loose to see what they would do in it
What are some hobbies or interests you enjoy when you’re not writing?
I am at the age where I’ve had to retire from Swordfighting, although my Hand-and-a-half stil l hangs from my office wall. I do still practice with firearms and I have a guilt pleasure pastime of repurposing old electronics – I come from that generation that was raised to turn egg cartons into everything but a place to put your eggs.
Now in days I also spend a lot of my spare time playing board and card games with my boys. They love to find new and interesting ways to play their old favorites and I keep up as best I can
Is there anything about you that readers might be surprised to learn?
Most of my career has been in computers. I’ve taught a computer lab in an elementary, been an IT technician, a software engineer, and even done helpdesk support. A lot of people are surprised to find out I’ve done so much technology when I refuse to use generative AI for my writing or the book covers. Just because you know how to do something though, doesn’t mean its what you or your readers want.
What advice would you give aspiring fantasy or LitRPG authors who are just starting out?
Don’t fall into the trap of saying need to be a perfect writer. Write short stories. Write Novellas that don’t go anywhere. Write fan fiction. A lot of people will tell you that you need to sit down, write the perfect American novel, and launch your bestseller career in one fell swoop, but that is not how it works. The writers we idolize have written a lot of bad fiction, but writing that awful dialog taught them how to write good dialog. Getting stuck halfway through an action scene taught them how to set up a better one. Write at your current level and give yourself honest feedback, then write again. Authors aren’t oracles, they are people who found a craft they were willing to be bad at long enough to get good at it.
🚀 Looking Ahead
Can readers expect more adventures in the world of Cold Steel Mac?
I wrote Cold Steel Mac to be standalone, but am ultimately leaving that decision up to the fans at Royal Road and Patreon. If enough people enjoy the book or follow the novel, I can certainly add more volumes to Cold Steel Mac. Mac and his god haven’t quite figured things out after all, and there is still the question of Holoch’s last safety patch threatening to set the planet on fire….
Are you currently working on any new projects you can share with readers?
A second LitRpg is in the works, this one with a more science fiction bend and with a Collectible Card Game mechanic. Its about two thirds of the way through a rough draft, with an expected release sometime in 2027. The characters for this novel are very different from Mac, so I’m excited to see what people think.
What would you like readers to know before they dive into Cold Steel Mac: Defy the Gods?
Cold Steel Mac is a celebration of free will. Expect to see the familiar systems set up, but don’t expect things to stay that way. Mac doesn’t consider himself beholden to anyone’s expectations, not even mine.
If readers finish the book and remember just one thing about it, what do you hope that will be?
Mac proves that it is never too late to become a better person or to make better decisions. Just because you’ve been a villain or a victim in the past doesn’t meant you have to be again. Mac’s key lesson is that at any point, we can burn down all of our suppositions about ourselves and the world and build new ones in their place.
💬 Final Thoughts
What has been the most rewarding part of sharing this story with readers?
Reader questions, hands down. If people are asking questions about the world, then I know I’ve done something right. That tells me that I’ve built a world not only with enough mystery for questions, but with enough room for people to ask what they would do in Mac’s place.
Is there anything else you would like to share with your readers and the Book Cast Media audience?
Only to keep reading. There is a lot of pressure to optimize everything these days and to focus on just one or two things to our own determent. That isn’t a path to being a happy person however. Allowing yourself to dabble and fail at things will give you the kind of stories to tell around the campfire when all those big impressive accomplishments are done. Experiment. Write, Sing, crack open a computer with no idea how to put it back together. Your failures will feed your successes.
In Closing:
Thanks to Alistair MacAoigh for joining us on BookCypher. If you’re curious what happens when a man who’s already died once decides he’s had enough of playing by someone else’s rules, pick up Cold Steel Mac: Defy the Gods and see what Mac does with his second chance.